Every journalist who runs to their editor so they can write a piece about the latest study of AI in education needs to read this essay. And everyone making dispositive claims in public about the impact of AI on education needs to read this as well.
Just what I needed to read today - an insightful unpicking of the different meanings of 'learning'. It also helps me reflect on why I simultaneously feel that AI has made me learn more and forget more than at any other period of my life.
Nice post. I would only say that ownership that matters is not of the product, but of the learning. Is you are solving lots of exercises on a topic, what matters is the feeling of owning comprehension of the topic, not of having produced that many solutions. Or is it that I have grown too theoretical?
The cognitive ownership point is what we are seeing too. In the last few months, we've talked to 70+ learners as we build Ediso. AI can clearly explain concepts. But when its time to generate something - build a project, make a decision, create something from scratch - learners get stuck. Because the whole time with AI, AI answered before they had a chance to think and form a position. That moment of generating, however messy and slow, is where ownership actually happens. and learning actually progresses.
So good. Framing the conflicting evidence as a definitional disconnect rather than a real contradiction is a really useful lens.
Every journalist who runs to their editor so they can write a piece about the latest study of AI in education needs to read this essay. And everyone making dispositive claims in public about the impact of AI on education needs to read this as well.
Just what I needed to read today - an insightful unpicking of the different meanings of 'learning'. It also helps me reflect on why I simultaneously feel that AI has made me learn more and forget more than at any other period of my life.
Nice post. I would only say that ownership that matters is not of the product, but of the learning. Is you are solving lots of exercises on a topic, what matters is the feeling of owning comprehension of the topic, not of having produced that many solutions. Or is it that I have grown too theoretical?
The cognitive ownership point is what we are seeing too. In the last few months, we've talked to 70+ learners as we build Ediso. AI can clearly explain concepts. But when its time to generate something - build a project, make a decision, create something from scratch - learners get stuck. Because the whole time with AI, AI answered before they had a chance to think and form a position. That moment of generating, however messy and slow, is where ownership actually happens. and learning actually progresses.